Who pays in a 50/50 car accident?

Frequently Asked Questions

Who pays in a 50/50 car accident?

In a personal injury case where both parties are equally at fault for the car accident, each party will be responsible for 50% of the other driver’s damages.  California is a fault state, which means that the insurance company of the at-fault driver is responsible for the damages caused by their insured.  It also follows the pure comparative negligence system, where a person’s claim for compensation is reduced by the percentage that they are at fault for an accident.

Under these two legal theories, each person who is at fault in a car accident is legally obligated to pay for the other person’s damages.  However, the recovery of each driver is reduced by the amount that they are at fault — 50%. A California personal injury attorney can help to establish that the other driver in a car accident case was 50% or more at fault.

This does not necessarily mean that it is a “wash,” because two drivers in a car accident case may have very different damages.  One driver may suffer far more serious injuries, requiring much more intensive — and expensive — medical care.  Or perhaps one driver has an older vehicle with a low value, while the other drove an expensive sports car.  In these situations, 50% of one driver’s damages will likely be much higher than the other driver’s losses.

For example, Joe and Mary are in a car accident where they are equally at fault.  Joe walks away from the car accident with just a few bruises, but his car — a  2015 Toyota — is totaled.  On the other hand, Mary broke her leg and will be out of work for over a month.  She is a doctor and earns a high salary, so her lost wages will be significant.  Her 2018 Range Rover sustained some damages, but is still drivable.  In this case, Joe may have $20,000 worth of damages, while Mary’s damages could top $100,000.  50% of Joe’s damages is $10,000 — but 50% of Mary’s damages is $50,000.  This demonstrates that even when each driver is equally at fault for an accident, they may receive vastly different amounts of compensation.

Law Offices of Fernando D. Vargas Located at
8647 Haven Avenue Suite 200, Rancho Cucamonga, CA.
Law Offices of Fernando D. Vargas Logo Phone: 909-982-0707